to keep intact a mandatory program and make 16 years
Towards the end of a typically overwhelming performance at the Hay Festival in May, during which Niall Ferguson denied history as taught in this country, attention turned to the public to reveal the new Education Secretary Michael Gove, had snuck into the event and sat somewhere near the back. And after a few exchanges not entirely convincing surprises along the lines of "Do you want to count on you" "You are wonderful", "No, you're wonderful," Gove Ferguson offered a job in place to help reform the curriculum the story.
The message of the two was evident. The country had gone to the dogs, and teaching of history was partly to blame. Under 13 years of a Labour government, school children of the nation had learned more than a few soundbites episodes on the Nazis, and therefore had no actual knowledge of, or pride, the past achievements of the country. Replace Britain, celebrating the past, forget the post-colonial apologetics, and the little guys will stop stabbing each other and the lower back and start looking for a job. There was a post-election story for the new coalition government seeking to reassure the country of the heart of the territory of a homecoming, common sense approach to education has been firmly in hand.
wisely, perhaps, Gove has chosen to consult not only Ferguson. Instead, using the address book that mysteriously opens the new ministers also invited several well-known historians, including Simon Schama and Richard Evans, to bring their suggestions for the comprehensive reform of education of history. Somewhere not too far in the process, has also asked David Cannadine, Dodge Professor of History at Princeton - and, with Ferguson and Schama, one of the main exports of the UK university in the United States - for their thoughts. Eighteen months after the line, Gove and you do not want that.
Like Gove, and Ferguson, Cannadine also had a keen interest in how history is taught in public schools, unlike them, he did not believe the rumors and rely on ideology was the best way to decide public policy. "There have been many theories about how the story he had learned over time," Cannadine said, "but no one had done any research to provide detailed evidence to support them." Then two years ago Cannadine and a half, with two researchers, Jenny Keating and Nicola Sheldon, funded by the Linbury and the Institute of Historical Research, set out to find empirical data, and this week the results are published in the right kind of history .
What is clear is that there never was a golden age of the teaching of history in which all sentimental left school knowing the names and dates of each King and Queen, or enjoying one last triumphant. "If you go through the records," says Cannadine, "it is clear that until the Second World War history is taught only to a very small elite, and even then it was hardly a theme dominant. Together with Albania You are one of the few countries in which the story is not mandatory above 14. And with only two or three hours per week schedule until that age, the opportunities for students to gain a broad base on the subject are rare. "
Cannadine not think the fault lies with the national program, which was introduced under the Thatcher government in 1988 in response to similar concerns that the standards of education has been reduced and something needs to be did. "It has become fashionable to call the history curriculum for being too episodic and students do not learn enough about how the interconnections past, but the real problem is that there is enough time to teach everything "says Cannadine. "If you look closely at the history curriculum, it covers almost everything you may want students to know, the problem is that there is enough time to teach it is inevitable that they will gaps in people and always learn .. So, even before the national program. In 1930, Tudor was the equivalent of the Nazis of today, with everyone complaining students spent time in more Tudor style at the expense of other periods. "
Moreover, history has included many more fields of study in schools over the past 50 years, where once mostly limited to wars, diplomacy and economy somewhat, which now includes race, gender and social issues. As a further dilution of the subject remains within a specified period was almost inevitable.
If the history curriculum is not adapted to the purpose and Cannadine believes that we should look beyond politicians and Whitehall for the guilty, as when Kenneth Baker
- were curriculum development in the original 80 was always the intention that history should be compulsory until age 16. At the last minute, however, Kenneth Clarke, then education secretary, has decided to maintain the status quo, and since then, history teachers have been forced to put an original program to learn more than five years three. As a direct result, students who chose to continue the story of GCSE were often forced to cover much of the same program in four key stages as they did in the Key Stage 3 - only much deeper. You do not need a lot of work to realize why so many students complain that the story is repetitive and boring.
- Cannadine believes the answer is simple. Leave him alone and return to resume the teaching of the way it was always intended to be taught, and it is compulsory until age 16. "I'm not naive," he said. "I'm pretty sure that in some schools of history is not always taught, that it should be. Should never be complacent about the rules. But the same is almost certainly nothing but you care to mention and no one is proposing a comprehensive reform of the curriculum in these areas. "
School For Ferguson, the gap of history in a story arc has some problems of interpretation. And if it is limited to a few class university is likely to serve a purpose. Ferguson has spent his career in counterfactual history right of defense and out of fashion, and if it has forced other liberal scholars to rethink and defend their positions more carefully, it is. However, Cannadine believes he should have no role in the way history is taught in school.
"History should never be used merely as a means for transmitting a desired national narrative," he said. "Putin is doing just that in Russia at the time to insist that certain aspects the Soviet regime should be taught in a more sympathetic. There are also calls in some U.S. states to rewrite their teaching of slavery. This can not be right. If a country has reason to feel uneasy about his past, then so be it should be adult enough to face that does not mean you should wallow in guilt, .. instead we should accept good or bad, without giving more importance either. "
Find best price for : --Guardian----Sheldon----Govian----Thatcher----Nicola----Keating----Jenny----David----Schama----Ferguson----Niall----Festival----Gove----Michael----Cannadine--
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(650)
-
▼
November
(149)
- It's worth staying up, if only to avoid a night in...
- Threats and arrests in Uganda | Richard M Kavuma
- Britain's life expectancy can be raised with a bit...
- This brutality is not Islam | Mehdi Hasan
- Politics is bad for our health | Jonathan Waxman
- Vital safeguard of right to lawyer in police stati...
- 'Borussia Barcelona' set up top-of-the-table clash...
- We're all paying for Europe's gift to our aristocr...
- Clubbers should be able to test their ecstasy | Da...
- Letters: Labour, solidarity and the pensions strike
- Social mobility is not a myth
- If you chose to emulate the life of Christ, can yo...
- Saudi Arabia needs a more transparent justice system
- Time to target gun control | Rodrigo Camarena
- Public sector strike: 'we have to live too'
- Egypt elections - live updates
- England riots: the personal cost
- These riots reveal some unpalatable home truths | ...
- Court of appeal upholds riot sentences
- The fiscal case for legalising marijuana | Samanth...
- Why does China love Shakespeare? | Frances Wood
- It's all a far cry from ancient Greece, but hubris...
- A short story of academic oppression in Egypt | Am...
- How Bob Crow is saving the economy | Aditya Chakra...
- Do lawyers still need a suit and tie - or formal f...
- Guardian journalist questioned over alleged phone-...
- Cribsheet 08.07.11
- The Bundle: Bigwigs off
- 'Complacency is a disastrous word'
- The Joy of Six: British and Irish footballers abro...
- Wenger satisfied with recovery month
- In today's debt crisis, Germany is the US of 1931 ...
- Attacks on climate scientists are the real 'climat...
- Climate scientists defend work in wake of new leak...
- Leave history alone but teach it for longer, says ...
- Leave history alone but teach it for longer, says ...
- Majority verdict: we already have a bill of rights...
- Society daily 22.11.11
- Moroccan voters set to back king's new constitution
- After a year to forget, Wayne Rooney is at his bes...
- Peter Lovatt: 'Dancing can change the way you think'
- Public sector pensions: What is fair? | Head to head
- Banning referral fees won't put the brakes on the ...
- Michele Bachmann's Iowa circus | Amanda Marcotte
- Do your bit for the rich. Sell your body parts | K...
- Manchester City exude confidence ahead of clash wi...
- Get Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall out of the dog hou...
- Why am I so excited about 11/11/11?
- Baha Mousa inquiry criticises the British troops' ...
- Wicked's appeal proves evergreen
- Arsène Wenger keeps faith with Arsenal's training ...
- David Miliband: Gaza represents the ultimate failu...
- Cribsheet 11.11.11
- Eta expected to announce end to violence
- Cribsheet 16.11.11
- Young jobseekers told to work without pay or lose ...
- Society daily 17.11.11
- Reading the Riots study to examine causes and effe...
- We need to keep talking about cervical cancer
- Shell has admitted liability but has a long way to...
- David Bedford obituary
- Do cuts kill?
- The Fiver | A cold school-night in November; and s...
- Society daily 15.11.11
- Letting technocrats run Europe is bad politics and...
- Inflation eases as food prices fall
- US politics live blog: Supreme Court healthcare ch...
- Libya shows signs of slipping from Muammar Gaddafi...
- Libya shows signs of slipping from Gaddafi's grasp
- Ai Weiwei released from detention
- How best to tackle corruption?
- 'Dancing can change the way you think'
- Aleks Krotoski: how free are we to choose our onli...
- Yulia Tymoshenko's daughter: 'My mother's trial wa...
- What's human? What's animal? And what of the biolo...
- Fabio Capello relishes the contribution of England...
- Age is a continuum - not two tribes to be made equ...
- Sarah Millican's dirty laugh - interview
- Access to justice is a fine concept. What does it ...
- Stronger civil society means more power for the weak
- Are science teachers using experiments as props in...
- At least Lord Coe is up to speed | Victoria Coren
- Ignore the warnings about legal aid changes and ri...
- Riot jail sentences in crown courts longer than no...
- Teachers must think internet-first
- UK tuition fees are third highest, says OECD
- UK tuition fees are third highest in developed wor...
- UN: World will miss economic benefit of 1.8 billio...
- I ditched my Oxford master's to give myself a bett...
- I ditched my Oxford master's to give myself a bett...
- Monsanto - the black stain on the biotech industry...
- Libya's main university prepares new term for a ne...
- Safet Susic calls on Bosnia to find belief for Eur...
- In liberated Libya in the year 2961 | Moez Zeiton
- FA Cup first round - live!
- Estonia v Republic of Ireland - as it happened | B...
- Marie Stopes: a turbo-Darwinist ranter, but right ...
- Fans pay respects to Jimmy Savile
- The meaning of 9/11's most controversial photo | J...
- Phone-hacking scandal: Stuart Kuttner is latest No...
-
▼
November
(149)
0 comments:
Post a Comment