Have a Good NEWS

Adam Wagner examines the responses to the consultation on a draft law on the rights in the UK

one way or another, at the end of this parliamentary rights protection in the UK will be very different. If you could get out of sight of the actor Hugh Grant giving evidence of research Leveson hacking phone, the main event of the live broadcast Legal Bonanza yesterday was the second debate on the bill and the penalties for corporate offenders House of Lords.

Although the project is likely to happen, is likely to do so under a slightly modified form -. Tweeters report predicts that domestic violence and the provisions of clinical negligence were more likely to be affected

Meanwhile, the Commission on a Bill of Rights, the Committee somewhat dysfunctional combing through the responses to the consultation recently closed. I have compiled some of the answers below, mostly people who have sent. The following is a summary of all scientists.

Freedom: No surprises here:. "Freedom believes that all Convention rights established by the HRA deserve protection and we can not imagine willingly part with any of these vital safeguards against the oppression of state also felt that the enforcement mechanisms available and only facilitated by the HRA account minimum for the implementation of the rights of any bill in the UK rights. "

The Bar "as the main function of a bill of rights is the protection of minority rights, you should consider include adequate protections for migrants and asylum seekers ... The Bar Association opposes the inclusion of a responsibility BoR ... strongly opposed a decision to the Court of Human Rights to be replaced by PACE and or the Committee of Ministers. . Economic, Social and Cultural Rights should be included in any public consultation. "

University of Cambridge, Faculty of Law: an intelligent and concise: "One of the ambitions of the HRA was to allow human rights to be prosecuted in national courts ... This ambition is carried out, although the mythology surrounding the HRA has substantially distorted the public perception of its effects. In this context, it is certainly a case to promote a better understanding of the obligations of the United Kingdom under the ECHR ... if the adoption of a "bill of rights in the UK" would be of a piece with the aim to demystify human rights is, however, open to doubt. "

British Institute of Human Rights: "With this bill of rights debate may seem like an opportunity to seek legal protection for a wide range of rights than those of the ARH, but we have serious reservations that this is not what is on the table and, in fact, that human rights may be weakened. The emphasis on expanding the list of human rights that are protected may (even unconsciously) over emphasize the importance of mechanisms to make these rights enforceable. "

Equality South West: They fear that the consultation was not sufficiently widespread and affected by the political rhetoric of the Prime Minister and Interior Minister: "It is our view that any Bill of Rights must be complementary to the Law on Human Rights and replace it. If it had been written in such a way as to help educate and inform individuals and agencies about their rights and responsibilities under the Human Rights Act would be a positive and constructive development. "

Commissioner for Children: Increases the potential for economic and social rights, which are on the wish list for some people to COMBOR, but it seems an unlikely result, especially because the likely cost to the public purse "We support the inclusion of serious economic, social and cultural rights in a Bill of Rights in the United Kingdom ... the interdependence of these rights and the indivisibility of civil and political rights of children highlighted in the CRC ... "

, London School of Economics: Professor Klug knows that the bill of rights, having studied and written about him for years. In short, have one and all that is new should be a Human Rights Act "and": "To ensure a new bill of rights respected the terms of reference of the committee, no additional fee required to cover new grounds , seamlessly complement the ECHR rights. It can be shown to improve the protection of human ... On the basis of our comparative research on the bills of rights, there is no example that we are in a reporting Rights was adopted to reduce the responsibility of the executive or legislative action in the courts, rather than the reverse. "

Scotland: A network of 34 human rights organizations in Scotland that are not "convinced" that the case of a bill of rights has been done so far, and in fact "are concerned about the failure to address the real problem is the lack of compliance with the explicit Human Rights Act in the UK and believe the powers of government should be invested in making the equal enjoyment of human rights a reality for ordinary people in the UK. "

obiter J: The blogger known legal supports a Human Rights Act "and more", arguing that international obligations on the rights of children must be integrated as well as potentially "put" is some of our laws Modern oldest, as the Bill of Rights of 1688 and the rest of the Magna Carta. "

Find best price for : --Wagner----College----SAMH----School----London----Klug----Francesca----PACE--