Of course there is no excuse for wanton criminality - as the prime minister, the archbishop of Canterbury and the leader of the opposition all said in a dutiful chorus and which was echoed afterwards by many of the repentant looters themselves in the magistrates' courts. But that does not help us much. We need to know why, and we need to get beyond invocations to better policing, tougher penalties and better parenting, however much they may be needed as part of the solution. The emergent consensus is that there was not even a higher political or social purpose behind what happened: it was mindless, feral youths and gangs - their members unparented - looting for the flat-screen TVs and trainers to which they wrongly felt entitled. It was an abysmal new social low.
But there were also dimensions (Alex and his "droogs") alongside Lord of the Flies
This should come as no surprise. Laura Johnson, of course, from a £ 1m house in Orpington, or Alexis Bailey, a classroom assistant in an elementary school, were apparently favored by the looters caught. Just as baby boomers, rich and poor alike, were part of a larger common life experiences are so today 's under 30s.
The Unicef ??report that set in 2007 Britain bottom of 21 industrialized countries in the way their children are treated not just single out child poverty as a cause of the problem - other factors include the factory-like education and training system, poor relationships with family and friends, low subjective well-being and the risks of everyday life.
In addition, image private shopping centers to collect any public place for children, insufficient and now includes youth clubs, routinely by the police, simply because less than 25 put into question, and then ordered to disperse, even if only two of them allow - all these impact on an entire age group. The dutiful can not riots young hard work for their skills, qualifications and training. But even they could ask for to be awarded: for what?
The country's stagnant economy. For everyone, young and unhappy in a broad valley to our goods by the misfortune of being trapped birth, what chance is there? Their prospects are vanishing points earned in any way or fair? And the bigger question that hangs over them all - Where is England?
Meanwhile, take with those at the top as much as they can get away. It is simply accepted that the highest tax rate is without purpose, because so many organize their affairs to not pay - even famous knights like Richard Branson or Philip Green, now reportedly considering a portion of its business in Switzerland. There is no word of disapproval of our financial and political elite, but both enjoy knighthoods, and how the Murdochs, privileged access to the top.
This requires a recognition that we examine our society in the round. It all connects. The wellbeing of the top and middle depends on the relative wellbeing and opportunities of those at the bottom. Societies cohere or they perish. England on this score fares astonishingly badly. Our social housing estates are, in Lynsey Hanley's words, vast people lockers. Once in, very few move out. A third of the bottom 10% of wage earners in 2001/2, reports the Work Foundation's Bottom 10 Million programme, were still there in 2008/9. Once unemployed, you are twice as likely to stay unemployed.
Already the police leadership is challenging this narrative; vengeful policing as the arm of a politicised police state but with far fewer resources is doomed to make matters worse. But the rest of us should make common cause. What happened last week was enormous, and it requires a better thought-through response than Mr Cameron's. Of course the unprecedented rapidity and severity of the spending cuts - on everything from educational maintenance allowances to youth clubs and the police - have contributed to the malaise and must make matters worse. But they are not its cause, which runs deeper still.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(650)
-
▼
August
(53)
- Gaddafi loyalists in Sirte refuse to surrender
- Libya: Gaddafi loyalists refuse to surrender - liv...
- I'm not angry with Edith any more
- Libya: rebels demand return of Gaddafi's family - ...
- Project Nim reminds us of our responsibility to th...
- The confessions of a teenage tourist
- The New Atheism
- Aston Villa v Wolverhampton Wanderers - as it happ...
- Liverpool v Bolton Wanderers - as it happened | Sc...
- Hurricane Irene: live updates
- Cribsheet 25.08.11
- The Fiver | A bona fide Cinderella story | Paul Doyle
- Ben Bernanke Jackson Hole speech: as it happened
- Pakistan needs courage - and help - to fight intol...
- Cribsheet 24.08.11
- GCSE results day 2011 - live blog
- Libya: the fall of Tripoli - live updates
- Corruption in India: 'All your life you pay for th...
- A dangerous misreading of the Boston Tea Party fro...
- Saturday clockwatch - live!
- Summerhill school and the do-as-yer-like kids
- Arsenal v Liverpool - as it happened | Scott Murray
- Libya: the battle for Tripoli - live updates
- Fighting continues on streets of Tripoli as Saif a...
- Letters: A-level results and critical thinking
- Top Girls; The Mother; Around the World in Eighty ...
- Overrated and overpaid but not over here, thanks |...
- Student essentials - and where to get them on a bu...
- The genius who lives downstairs | Alexander Master...
- Cribsheet 10.08.11
- The Right Word: Fox News fears riots | Sadhbh Walshe
- UK riots: don't shut these kids out now | Suzanne ...
- Greece's healthcare system is on the brink of cata...
- Greek healthcare system on the brink
- England riots: Clegg and May speeches and reaction...
- A working life: the drag queen
- UK riots: Our wounded nation will not be healed by...
- Cribsheet 28.07.11
- Coalition cuts are making life tough for mothers
- Badgers culls don't stop tuberculosis in cattle - ...
- West Midlands riots: tense and weary residents tak...
- The Saturday interview: Nadine Dorries
- AFC Wimbledon v Bristol Rovers - as it happened | ...
- Saturday Clockwatch - as it happened | Alan Gardner
- Meet Chicago's Interrupters…
- Follow the live action with Clockwatch
- Dietmar Hamann: 'It's different to World Cup but i...
- England v India - live! | Alan Gardner and Rob Bagchi
- Premier League preview No4: Bolton Wanderers | Jac...
- League Two 2011-12 season preview: the bloggers' view
- League One 2011-12 preview: the bloggers' view
- Greece's 'won't pay' anti-austerity revolt
- Cribsheet 01.08.11
-
▼
August
(53)
0 comments:
Post a Comment