Roman Polanski's Lifetime Achievement reminds us that art should never be judged by the morality of the artist
Remember that bit at the end of The Pianist where the character of Adrien Brody plays the piano by his Nazi sensor? Would not it make you feel a tingling on the skin? You can not crush your soul at the thought of all the cruelty and destruction of the Holocaust, and the juxtaposition of the flood of music that hopefully in the field of art lifts us all? Or maybe you were too busy thinking about the effect that the person who directed the movie was guilty of having sex with a minor and was unable to take advantage of something he had created.
Todaydirector Roman Polanski films such as Chinatown and pianist, visiting Zurich to finally get his Lifetime Achievement Award, two years after they gave him. Its late acceptance is due to the fact that he was arrested and remanded in custody first time, with the intention of extraditing him to the United States and have him serve his sentence, he fled more than 30 years.
I think it's wonderful to receive this award, but in no way defend as a person. Many people try to justify their behavior, encapsulated famous by Whoopi Goldberg "It was not rape-rape", but irrelevant. I do not know and I will not comment on his apparent intelligence or grace solemn. If he did rape or seduce the girl in 1977, while it's disgusting, despite his pregnant wife was murdered in 1967, or the survivor of the Holocaust in Poland as a child, when nearly 90% of the Jewish population was killed, including his own mother.
None of this really matters to anyone but him, regarding the prize, his personal history is completely irrelevant. Art should never be judged by looking at the artist. It is essential to separate the two, otherwise it would have disastrous consequences for creativity. If you wiped out all the art created by people morally reprehensible, we lack some of our most treasured songs, paintings, buildings and books.
- In his essay of 1967 the author's death, French philosopher Roland Barthes asserts that when a writer creates his work, from his birth. This is an independent, and able to live an unpredictable life, like a child. It is beyond the control of the author, and vice versa. Just as you should not judge a person looking at where they come from, or raised, as are works of art.
I think people in general are good at doing that. Amy Winehouse was a drug user self-Harmer and had a notoriously violent marriage. Not exactly a good role model, but is simply praised for having one of the best voices of his generation. TS Eliot was an anti-Semite, but has been studied in my university, where teachers unapologetically called him a genius. Einstein was a womanizer, but this week has been discussed with affection and admiration for his contributions to physics.
Find best price for : --Polanski----Barthes----Roland----Roman--
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(407)
-
▼
March
(110)
- Far Cry 3 Gets A Bit Crazier
- The Amazing Spiderman trailer swings in
- Walkthrough: 'Doctor Who: Worlds In Time'
- Origin offers Steam 'healthy competition' - Minecr...
- ShopTo drops 'bad taste' GAME Reward Card offer
- Wha' Happened: Spinach Festival Day
- West Brom 1-3 Newcastle
- Deus Ex: Human Revolution - Augmented Edition unbo...
- Around the network: festive edition
- 'Diablo 3' Skills Guide For The Barbarian, Demon H...
- 'Uncharted 3' Beta Now Open To Everyone On PSN
- This Week's Top Stories: March 19 - 24, 2012
- Bethesda tight-lipped on possible Prey 2 cancellation
- Draw Something reinvents Pictionary for the mobile
- 'Batman: Arkham City' PC Delayed Until November
- Look to banks to reduce use of payday loans
- Drink and drugs are to blame for violence in the y...
- Pao by Kerry Young - review
- Coalition 'is putting women's lives at risk'
- Herman Cain to make 'major announcement' about cam...
- Cain to make 'major announcement'
- China to step up social media censorship
- Secrecy laws 'don't harm the work of ministers', s...
- How comedy audiences learned to laugh with science...
- A Force to Be Reckoned With: A History of the Wome...
- St Johnstone 3-3 Dundee United
- There's a wealth of data out there - why not let u...
- E3 2011 Xbox 360 Press Conference Live Stream
- The archbishop of Canterbury's balancing act | Rup...
- Phone hacking: let's break up this information car...
- What If Ron Paul wins Iowa? | Ana Marie Cox
- Some referees are damaging image of Premier League...
- Evangelicals and Mormons: divided on theology, uni...
- It's worth remembering: press freedom is a messy b...
- Liverpool 1-1 Sunderland
- Universities: Summer assessment
- I'm going to try to be like an arts critic, but fo...
- Whatever his crimes, Roman Polanski deserves his a...
- The Eurosceptic isolationists are in the saddle | ...
- University accommodation website provides home fro...
- Andorra 0-2 Republic of Ireland
- Vitamin pills can lead you to take health risks
- Vitamin pills can lead you to take health risks | ...
- Some of these proposed free schools could cause co...
- Burma's push for freedom is held back by its insti...
- We dared to resist the forced academy conversion o...
- Society daily 20.03.12
- Illinois primary day and Republican budget proposa...
- Yunus Rahmatullah: left in a Bagram black hole by ...
- Yunus Rahmatullah: left in a Bagram black hole by ...
- Case law on injunctions is still the preserve of t...
- Emotions running high between Ken Bates and Leeds ...
- Mere posturing from the Tories on forced marriage ...
- Nuts to your red meat reproaches | Nicholas Lezard
- Rick v Rick: Perry earmarks Santorum for attack ad...
- Legal aid alternatives deserve government support
- Private schools win case over showing benefit to s...
- Stop this anti-sex drive | Zoe Margolis
- Football transfer rumours: Arsenal or Spurs to sig...
- Abu Qatada's release - what would the jihadists th...
- One year on, the 16-19 bursary is a shambles | Ror...
- Richard Dawkins has uncovered a very British form ...
- Labour's childcare plans will help families work
- Greece on the breadline: how leftovers became a meal
- Rowan Williams: a good man, an impossible task
- This judgment in favour of kettling is a missed op...
- Just a phase? No, the student protests over fees a...
- The 'unnatural' Ashley treatment can be right for ...
- Capture the drama, it's rocket science!
- Letters: How schools prepare the citizens of the f...
- Paul Simon brings Graceland back to London, 25 yea...
- Pupil premium 'spread too widely' to help poorest ...
- English that's good enough | Marina Warner
- Game Change's gift of an improbable dignity to Sar...
- The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt - review
- The Fiver | Marshmallow seats; and history lessons...
- Alabama and Mississippi primary results: GOP panel...
- Precognition or 'future sight' and the curse of th...
- Student day of action: protests over government's ...
- Hugh Grant: 'I love getting into a taxi and saying...
- Portal 2 PC motion control levels out
- GDC Podcast: Capy, Kickstarter, SpaceChem and Zigg...
- Minecraft's Persson: It's 'dangerous' to allow Ste...
- Championship round-up: Reading go second after 1-1...
- London mayor: your ideas for policy on the economy...
- F2P Summit Early Bird deadline nears
- Daily Mail writes positive video games story; Porc...
- This Week's Top Stories: August 15 - 20, 2011
- This Week's Top Stories: February 13 - 18, 2012
- Mad Bombs 2
- NHS reform is needed to meet the challenges of the...
- 'Fly upstart Virgin, not the fat cats of BA' - Cam...
- Theresa May to visit Jordan for Abu Qatada deporta...
- The new anti-science assault on US schools | Kathe...
- Brac programme lifting 'ultra-poor' out of poverty...
- Palestinian hunger striker Khader Adnan 'near deat...
- Why the Bideford ruling on council prayers is a se...
- Elected city mayors will transform the English pol...
- John Gage
- Nigeria hostage raid was discussed by Italy and UK...
-
▼
March
(110)
0 comments:
Post a Comment